Wednesday, December 28, 2005
-THE CUNNING REALIST-: Reeds In The Wind
-THE CUNNING REALIST-: Reeds In The Wind
Reeds In The Wind
One of the recurring themes of this blog has been the way in which many self-described "conservatives" have been exposed as little more than opportunistic hypocrites during the past few years. It's both fascinating and a bit sad, because a decade ago I considered some of these people or their employers in the media to be standard-bearers of clear thinking when the premium on that was dear.I don't know much about Mark Levin other than he's an attorney who contributes frequently to National Review. I also recall that during the Clinton administration he was a vocal critic of both the president and Janet Reno, particularly on the subject of intrusive government. One of Levin's pet issues was the shootout at Ruby Ridge in 1992, in which the FBI and U.S. Marshals laid siege to Randy Weaver and his family at a remote mountain cabin. Here are some excerpts from a longer piece Levin wrote in National Review in 1995 defending Weaver (my bolds):
The Weavers' ordeal began in 1989 when a confidential informant for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms persuaded Randy Weaver to sell him two sawed-off shotguns, thereby entrapping him. The ATF informant received $5,000 for his help. There is no indication that, prior to meeting the informant, Weaver had ever sold illegal weapons to anyone.The ATF then informed Weaver the United States attorney was considering bringing criminal charges against him for the gun sales, but might go easier on him if he turned informer against the Aryan Nations. Weaver refused, saying he would not become a "snitch."Weaver was then charged. But why had the ATF entrapped him in the first place? His views were and are repugnant to most Americans, but he was not involved in unlawful activities.There's more:
For an astonishing 18 months, marshals mounted a surveillance operation on the Weavers -- including 16-year-old Sara, 14-year-old Sammy, 10-year-old Rachel, and, later, 10-month-old Elisheba -- and their live-in family friend, Kevin Harris.And this:
Larry Potts, head of the FBI's criminal division, ordered the FBI's elite Hostage Rescue Team, commanded by Richard Rogers, to go to Ruby Ridge. Rogers, apparently concerned about protecting his men, drafted new rules of engagement, which departed dramatically from existing rules.The kicker: as Levin himself notes in the article, he wrote the above in response to testimony on Ruby Ridge heard by the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on---you guessed it---Terrorism.Levin was also a strident defender of civil liberties during the assault on the Branch Davidian compound in Waco, and---if memory serves---during the seizure of Elian Gonzalez and his forced return to Cuba. (Others on the Right were as well; here's an Ann Coulter piece in which she sympathetically calls David Koresh and the Branch Davidians "harmless American citizens" and Elian Gonzalez "a small Cuban boy.") Both incidents, of course, occurred during Bill Clinton's presidency.These days, Levin's singing a different tune. He's been an apologist for one abuse of power after another, from torture to NSA surveillance of U.S. citizens. This week, he defended John Yoo in this post at NRO, concluding with:
John Yoo deserves a medal. He's a patriot.During the 1990's, Levin carried the torch for Randy Weaver---criticizing government surveillance of a man Levin concedes had attended Aryan Nation meetings and trafficked in illegal weapons, decrying the FBI's secret drafting of new rules designed to get around existing rules of engagement, and advocating strong civilian oversight of the agencies of government power in order to safeguard civil liberties. And Levin did that in the context of Senate hearings on terrorism, arguing essentially that we can't allow terrorists to win by making us lose ourselves and our ideals to hysteria. Today, Levin is president of the John Yoo Fan Club and a tireless advocate of the chief executive's power to create new rules for conduct when existing ones are inconvenient. Quite a turnabout, eh? Can there be any doubt that if Ruby Ridge or Waco happened today, Mark Levin would be joined by others on the Titular Right in calling Randy Weaver and David Koresh "terrorists" against whom the full power of the U.S. government should be brought to bear?If the Democrats (particularly if it's Hillary Clinton) retake the White House in 2008, the sound you'll hear will be readers cackling as Levin and the other windblown reeds---driven by the exigencies of opportunism and reader subscriptions---come full circle and once again hoist the flag of outrage against intrusive government and abuse of power.And so it goes.
posted by The Cunning Realist at Tuesday, December 27, 2005
6 Comments:
scott_api said...
Not to disagree with you, TCR, but the sound you hear will be the bleating of sheep as the legions of FOX and Rush fans turn 180 degrees to follow their 'leaders' on this new crusade against intrusive government and executive power grabs...
12/27/2005 9:55 PM
Mitchell J. Freedman said...
I agree with the Cunning Realists' overall point, but Levin deserves a bit of defense since he did stand against the Bush I administration's treatment of the Weavers at Ruby Ridge. That event occurred in 1992 while Bush I was still president.Again, though, Levin's over the top attacks on Clinton for the Waco disaster (a left over project of the Bush I administration) and Clinton's protection of family values by rescuing Elian Gonzalez from clutching Miami relatives and hangers on cannot be reconciled in any honest way with a defense of the Terrible President's conduct over the past five years.Another example of the lack of integrity among the Terrible President's defenders.
12/28/2005 1:23 AM
mjs said...
Don't ever forget that "9/11 changed everything." Someone recently said, I believe it was Digby, that modern day conservatives are scared of their own shadows. They act like this country has never had enemies or been through difficult seasons. They are so afraid that otherwise thoughtful people will tolerate incremental destruction of our basic civil liberties.
12/28/2005 1:34 AM
mjs said...
On the other hand, they [M. Levin and the rest of the sycophants at NRO] may just be partisan whores.
12/28/2005 1:36 AM
debcoop said...
I think that if another Ruby Ridge or Waco occurred then people like Mark Levin might very well still be apologists for them because we remember that these two incidents, were committed not by the "other" but by right wingers just like him.It is not just the action that would be considered but the actor.
12/28/2005 2:04 AM
Anonymous said...
Nice post TCR, sums up a lot quite well.
12/28/2005 10:38 AM
Reeds In The Wind
One of the recurring themes of this blog has been the way in which many self-described "conservatives" have been exposed as little more than opportunistic hypocrites during the past few years. It's both fascinating and a bit sad, because a decade ago I considered some of these people or their employers in the media to be standard-bearers of clear thinking when the premium on that was dear.I don't know much about Mark Levin other than he's an attorney who contributes frequently to National Review. I also recall that during the Clinton administration he was a vocal critic of both the president and Janet Reno, particularly on the subject of intrusive government. One of Levin's pet issues was the shootout at Ruby Ridge in 1992, in which the FBI and U.S. Marshals laid siege to Randy Weaver and his family at a remote mountain cabin. Here are some excerpts from a longer piece Levin wrote in National Review in 1995 defending Weaver (my bolds):
The Weavers' ordeal began in 1989 when a confidential informant for the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms persuaded Randy Weaver to sell him two sawed-off shotguns, thereby entrapping him. The ATF informant received $5,000 for his help. There is no indication that, prior to meeting the informant, Weaver had ever sold illegal weapons to anyone.The ATF then informed Weaver the United States attorney was considering bringing criminal charges against him for the gun sales, but might go easier on him if he turned informer against the Aryan Nations. Weaver refused, saying he would not become a "snitch."Weaver was then charged. But why had the ATF entrapped him in the first place? His views were and are repugnant to most Americans, but he was not involved in unlawful activities.There's more:
For an astonishing 18 months, marshals mounted a surveillance operation on the Weavers -- including 16-year-old Sara, 14-year-old Sammy, 10-year-old Rachel, and, later, 10-month-old Elisheba -- and their live-in family friend, Kevin Harris.And this:
Larry Potts, head of the FBI's criminal division, ordered the FBI's elite Hostage Rescue Team, commanded by Richard Rogers, to go to Ruby Ridge. Rogers, apparently concerned about protecting his men, drafted new rules of engagement, which departed dramatically from existing rules.The kicker: as Levin himself notes in the article, he wrote the above in response to testimony on Ruby Ridge heard by the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on---you guessed it---Terrorism.Levin was also a strident defender of civil liberties during the assault on the Branch Davidian compound in Waco, and---if memory serves---during the seizure of Elian Gonzalez and his forced return to Cuba. (Others on the Right were as well; here's an Ann Coulter piece in which she sympathetically calls David Koresh and the Branch Davidians "harmless American citizens" and Elian Gonzalez "a small Cuban boy.") Both incidents, of course, occurred during Bill Clinton's presidency.These days, Levin's singing a different tune. He's been an apologist for one abuse of power after another, from torture to NSA surveillance of U.S. citizens. This week, he defended John Yoo in this post at NRO, concluding with:
John Yoo deserves a medal. He's a patriot.During the 1990's, Levin carried the torch for Randy Weaver---criticizing government surveillance of a man Levin concedes had attended Aryan Nation meetings and trafficked in illegal weapons, decrying the FBI's secret drafting of new rules designed to get around existing rules of engagement, and advocating strong civilian oversight of the agencies of government power in order to safeguard civil liberties. And Levin did that in the context of Senate hearings on terrorism, arguing essentially that we can't allow terrorists to win by making us lose ourselves and our ideals to hysteria. Today, Levin is president of the John Yoo Fan Club and a tireless advocate of the chief executive's power to create new rules for conduct when existing ones are inconvenient. Quite a turnabout, eh? Can there be any doubt that if Ruby Ridge or Waco happened today, Mark Levin would be joined by others on the Titular Right in calling Randy Weaver and David Koresh "terrorists" against whom the full power of the U.S. government should be brought to bear?If the Democrats (particularly if it's Hillary Clinton) retake the White House in 2008, the sound you'll hear will be readers cackling as Levin and the other windblown reeds---driven by the exigencies of opportunism and reader subscriptions---come full circle and once again hoist the flag of outrage against intrusive government and abuse of power.And so it goes.
posted by The Cunning Realist at Tuesday, December 27, 2005
6 Comments:
scott_api said...
Not to disagree with you, TCR, but the sound you hear will be the bleating of sheep as the legions of FOX and Rush fans turn 180 degrees to follow their 'leaders' on this new crusade against intrusive government and executive power grabs...
12/27/2005 9:55 PM
Mitchell J. Freedman said...
I agree with the Cunning Realists' overall point, but Levin deserves a bit of defense since he did stand against the Bush I administration's treatment of the Weavers at Ruby Ridge. That event occurred in 1992 while Bush I was still president.Again, though, Levin's over the top attacks on Clinton for the Waco disaster (a left over project of the Bush I administration) and Clinton's protection of family values by rescuing Elian Gonzalez from clutching Miami relatives and hangers on cannot be reconciled in any honest way with a defense of the Terrible President's conduct over the past five years.Another example of the lack of integrity among the Terrible President's defenders.
12/28/2005 1:23 AM
mjs said...
Don't ever forget that "9/11 changed everything." Someone recently said, I believe it was Digby, that modern day conservatives are scared of their own shadows. They act like this country has never had enemies or been through difficult seasons. They are so afraid that otherwise thoughtful people will tolerate incremental destruction of our basic civil liberties.
12/28/2005 1:34 AM
mjs said...
On the other hand, they [M. Levin and the rest of the sycophants at NRO] may just be partisan whores.
12/28/2005 1:36 AM
debcoop said...
I think that if another Ruby Ridge or Waco occurred then people like Mark Levin might very well still be apologists for them because we remember that these two incidents, were committed not by the "other" but by right wingers just like him.It is not just the action that would be considered but the actor.
12/28/2005 2:04 AM
Anonymous said...
Nice post TCR, sums up a lot quite well.
12/28/2005 10:38 AM
Potomac Sunrise
Merry Christmas to all my Flickr friends! I wish you could have been with me this morning, but here's the next best thing. Happy Holidays!
The tree
...and then It began to snow .. (see big version!)
In order to recharge the batteries, after a couple of Christmassy days, we set off to our favourite park in the town Towneley. It was crisp, cold and frosty but gorgeous!
In order to recharge the batteries, after a couple of Christmassy days, we set off to our favourite park in the town Towneley. It was crisp, cold and frosty but gorgeous!
Deer
Spotted on the way home from my Mom's house this Christmas Day. There was one more on the left that I didn't get in the shot.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)